Shopping Cart
Your Cart is Empty
Quantity:
Subtotal
Taxes
Shipping
Total
There was an error with PayPalClick here to try again
CelebrateThank you for your business!You should be receiving an order confirmation from Paypal shortly.Exit Shopping Cart

Blogs

Blogs

Estonia's Lessons in Cyber Warfare

Posted on January 14, 2013 at 1:05 PM

From US News Blog

What is a weapon of mass destruction? According to the Encyclopedia Britannica a weapon of mass destruction, known as WMD, is a

weapon with the capacity to inflict death and destruction on such a massive scale and so indiscriminately that its very presence in the hands of a hostile power can be considered a grievous threat. Modern weapons of mass destruction are either nuclear, biological, or chemical weapons—frequently referred to collectively as NBC weapons.

In fact, if you look up most definitions of WMD, nowhere is the mention of a cybersecurity threat being part of the equation.  While the conventional WMD are truly frightening to most of us, imagine the impact of a real cyberattack in the Western world. Power grids down, banking transactions failures, deliberate scrambling of healthcare or customer credit information, and deliberate mass transportation, commercial airspace, and shipping lines confusion, etc. There is, however, always the issue of how to identify whether a cyberattack is a weapon of "mass destruction or simply a weapon of mass distraction and inconvenience."  Even if a cyberattack is a mass distraction, besides from the inconvenience, the business costs could be astronomical.


Cyberattacks were elevated to warfare status in early 2007 when the tiny country of Estonia decided they were going to let the world know that their country was "under a cyberattack" by the Russians (the government), i.e. state sponsored cyberwarfare. What was claimed and later proven by the Estonians was that the Russians had launched a series of massive coordinated cyberattacks on the Estonian public and private sector in April 2007. Estonian banks, parliament, ministries, newspapers, and TV were bombard. This was all over an argument with the Russians over the reallocation of the "Bronze Soldier of Tallinn" and war graves in Tallinn (the capital of Estonia). This was the second largest state-sponsored cyberattack, second only to "Titan Rain," a series of coordinated attacks on U.S. computer systems between 2003-2006, thought to be of Chinese origin.

Estonia shouted loudly from the roof tops that they were being attacked, that an act of war had being committed by the Russians, and called upon its allies to assist, but they had a hard time getting anyone to believe that this was a "real war" and not a cybernuisance. In the end no one came to help the Estonians but what that alarm did do was to put global cyberattacks on the warfare discussion table for North Atlantic Treaty Organization, known as NATO. Why is it important? Well for starters Estonia happens to belong to NATO, which has something called Article 5 which goes something like this: "attack one of us, and it’s the same as attacking all of us"…along the lines of Alexander Dumas Musketeer slogan "Unus pro omnibus, omnes pro uno" which is Latin for "one for all, all for one." Article 5 is at

the basis of a fundamental principle of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO). It provides that if a NATO Ally is the victim of an armed attack, each and every other member of the Alliance will consider this act of violence as an armed attack against all members and will take the actions it deems necessary to assist the Ally attacked.

Ironically it was the United States that evoked Article 5 for the first time, in the aftermath of 9/11.


The Estonians were trying to evoke Article 5 when they were being attacked by the Russians in 2007, but thought better of it and did not evoke the article because of the lack of support from their NATO allies; NATO could not agree on the definition of "under attack" in this case and identifying and proving that this was a Kremlin-sponsored attack was difficult. The Estonians were left to fend for themselves.

The Estonians raised global awareness of state-sponsored cyberattacks. We will never know if Estonia was the first real "cyberwar" but it was the first time a country claimed publicly it was under attack. There are still many questions about cyberwarfare and cybersecurity that need to be addressed. For example, what is the threshold of cyberattacks so that a cybernuisance is reclassified as a cyberwar? Is it cyberwar if the perpetrator is a "geeky" kid next door launching an attack from his bedroom versus a state-sponsored group? Moreover, do we declare we are under attack only when the cyber targets are military/government installations or national power grids or even if private institutions are hit? Who do you go after, because usually cyberattacks "ping" themselves through a third party (country) computer server? And so on and so on.

Estonia spent the last six years becoming one of the best defended countries against a potential cyberattack (but with limited offensive capabilities). Today, almost six years later, the Estonian model is studied by many countries on how to build national defensive cybersecurity capability systems. This is of particular importance since the Estonians have a public-private business cybersecurity partnership model which is the envy of many countries.


Like most things, the issue is really now a legal one—about the rules of engagement in cyberwarfare (defensive and offensive), not only including the legal partnerships between a government and its pubic but with other nations. We know one thing for sure, if there is no public-private business partnership, real national cyberdefense is an illusion, and if there is no international convention allowing defensive and offensive actions, all countries are vulnerable regardless of their domestic cyber capabilities.

On a side note, I just got back from Tallinn, Estonia, where I was part of The George Washington University School of Business Executive MBA in Cyber Security Program in partnership with the GW Homeland Security Policy Institute under Frank Cilluffo, former White House special assistant to the president for Homeland Security. GW launched the first ever U.S. university-sponsored residency in Estonia on this issue of public-private business cybersecurity partnership. The GW executives in residence are still there on the ground in Estonia learning first-hand about the complexities of cyber security as this article is going to press. This is a "shout-out" to them for pioneering the future of cyber security. I expect Tallinn will soon be inundated with a proliferation of U.S. universities students interested in learning how to build public-private business cybersecurity programs.

 

Categories: US News Blog

Post a Comment

Oops!

Oops, you forgot something.

Oops!

The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.

Already a member? Sign In

8 Comments

Reply inalaFutFlene
9:31 PM on September 14, 2020 
casino bonus codes http://onlinecasinouse.com/# slots online casino real money online casino real money
Reply Unsorie
12:50 AM on April 26, 2022 
plug composed cleared warned along
http://www.krabuangyai.go.th/community/profile/maiabdul6763485 buying tudofovir online
http://www.debtrecoverydr.co.uk/community/profile/kirkboshears450
/ buy zelnorm order europe online
http://thehealthstudents.com/profile/concettafrome91/ where to order secnil
http://zedgazette.com/community/profile/hyegerber13001/ generic avana available
http://www.medexamprep.com/community/profile/alannaminor9679/ generic medex no prescription
http://goodbeta.co.za/community/profile/cherihursey5983/ buy trileptal in usa without prescription
http://www.singlemomspot.com/community/profile/philomenachambe/ i need a folic-acid
http://www.cellstarcorp.com/community/profile/latia4679751514/ money order now cheapest atomoxetine florida
http://checkyourlife.de/community/profile/georgehowells89/ buy metoclopramide romania
http://www.robusta.ai/forum1/profile/kelvin33p017177/ order lariam online
http://www.lavocedeicittadini.it/community/profile/shelahoolan754
0/ generic dicaris online order
http://www.placeofindia.com/forums/profile/augustax7841258/ cheap medications medication
http://www.cellstarcorp.com/community/profile/louvenianolen37/ medicine buy visa australia
http://www.lankadesha.com/community/profile/laylafrayne820/ happy family pharmacy coupon code
http://kosmotive.rw/kosmoparenting/profile/milfordbellasis/ where can i buy methylcobalamin
http://bittyspaceprogram.com/discussion/profile/adriangaunson52/ generic zithromax where to order florida
http://www.deadbeathomeowner.com/community/profile/selinacopley58
/ suprax no doctor
http://www.coolcasegallery.com/community/profile/maricruzgreatho/
buy paliperidone italia
http://keralaregistrationguru.com/ML/community/profile/orenbard27
26828/ generic aflamin order
http://cultfanclub.com/u1-fan-club/profile/marianax8945453/ buy ranexa united states
http://www.dumpsterdiving.no/samfunn/profile/toshabirdwood0/ home
https://pfauen-buffet.ch/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&ta
sk=user&id=88634 buy drug maxolon 1mg with mastercard
http://doktortonic.ru/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&task=
user&id=286086 buy now cozaar pills online store
http://softgrouprd.com/do/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&t
ask=user&id=475969&misotrol misotrol 400 mg bacterial vaginosis
https://rcg-ia.com/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&task=use
r&id=148770 cheapest retacnyl mail order payment
https://rcg-ia.com/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&task=use
r&id=148302 generic espercil purchase otc
https://www.psnfusion.com/content/index.php?option=com_k2&view=it
emlist&task=user&id=1678345 cheap travatan in florida
https://goodmam.ru/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&task=use
r&id=626718&quinine cheapest generic quinine 10mg in thailand
https://www.psnfusion.com/content/index.php?option=com_k2&view=it
emlist&task=user&id=1682294 money order amoxicillin pharmacy europe
https://goodmam.ru/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&task=use
r&id=626467&tibitol can i purchase tibitol visa usa
http://www.waix.com.br/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&task
=user&id=172870 where can i buy order 30mg
https://www.waix.com.br/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&tas
k=user&id=171658 seroflo for dogs
http://doktortonic.ru/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&task=
user&id=286296 buy oxybutynin 37.5mg online ireland
http://aptech.tstu.ru/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&task=
user&id=847784 purchase now cheap estrogel shopping canada
https://pfauen-buffet.ch/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&ta
sk=user&id=88289 cheapest order mail order pharmacy usa
marianne jumps shorts mock suffered
Reply Unsorie
11:05 PM on April 26, 2022 
signing chase solemn syrup
http://dialoguewithadoptees.org/community/profile/melodylevy85534
/ dilatrend pills buy now online
http://pictorobo.in/forum/profile/jorgangas50470/ buy favilavir fast delivery
http://rueda19.net.ar/community/profile/dorrisporras346/ generic lotensin purchase now florida
http://fundamental-life.com/forum/profile/eddyboh85523855/ cheapest purinethol canada
http://germanttc.com.au/community/profile/leannecleveland/ get meds cheaper
http://infotechapb.com/community/profile/kathieblackweld/ discount drug store hastings
http://susan-a-foundation.org/community/profile/kellyholguin175/ isoptin buy now online uk
http://sakwora.com/index.php/forum/profile/dinahburgoyne63/ generic drugs order
http://beedms.com/community/profile/justintaubman52/ buy levitra tokyo
http://checkyourlife.de/community/profile/antoinette54y28/ generic medicine buy europe
http://openlyvoluntary.com/Lets-think-forum/profile/ewanrichmond1
54/ buy alfacip best price
http://course.reallyedutech.com/community/profile/carolyngoodrich
/ buy levonorgestrel no prescription online
http://zetperformance.eu/community/profile/martin87h964818/ drug store discounts for seniors
http://nativelearners.com/community/profile/rockyoman831942/ how can i buy now tablets
http://hococomic.com/community/profile/kassandra508934/ cheap meds no prescription
http://piccolinomarkt.de/community/profile/ezekielwilks906/ purchase avirax austin
http://you-and-me-at-home.com/community/profile/earnest55v93285/ meds pills buy now online
http://rayfamilyco.com/community/profile/lavinaalfaro79/ low price meds
http://www.lemaster.com.br/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&
task=user&id=3030546 metformin-pioglitazone buy now shop europe
https://pilartorres.es/www/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&
task=user&id=669141 cheapest delestrogen where to buy payment
https://ppid.esdm.jatimprov.go.id/index.php?option=com_k2&view=it
emlist&task=user&id=169867&delagil buy delagil online 3 day delivery
http://ecofinders.com.br/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&ta
sk=user&id=1547264&quetiapine price quetiapine sale legally canada internet
http://autoinkoop247.nl/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&tas
k=user&id=288874 ordering cheap order
https://pilartorres.es/www/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&
task=user&id=669245&diamox where to purchase cheapest diamox visa
https://startnet.com.ua/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&tas
k=user&id=216648 order where to money order europe
https://goodmam.ru/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&task=use
r&id=630989 where can i buy avamigran california
http://ecofinders.com.br/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&ta
sk=user&id=1547251&otrivin-azelastine description du otrivin-azelastine
http://www.lemaster.com.br/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&
task=user&id=3031219 cheap chloroquine wholesalers
http://autoinkoop247.nl/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&tas
k=user&id=289202 buy tri-cyclen sale canada no script
https://goodmam.ru/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&task=use
r&id=630956&sarafem purchase generic sarafem order europe visa
http://itmaa.org/community/profile/rosalinaeusebio/ read all
laundry ken the privately
Reply Nokoppold
2:05 AM on May 6, 2022 
angeles profit traditional
http://checkyourlife.de/community/profile/dianejustus4894/ generic normodyne in usa
http://observationdeck.pegasusvideos.com/community/profile/julian
553925519/ fucidin cost without insurance
http://www.threshold-bd.com/community/profile/romancooke70799/ buy augmentin online cheap
http://astromania.es/foro/profile/roycebentham769/ buy estradiol sweden
http://sumoexpress.vn/diendan/profile/stephanysbs1995 buy poxet nz
http://checkyourlife.de/community/profile/rachelschuster/ cheap prices on medications
http://feassistant.com/forums/profile/renedouglass23/ buy medicine australia
http://asunfootball.com/community/profile/melva475144396/ lowest prices diprophos uk
http://poppingpaperbacks.com/category/community/forum/profile/car
inalow19602/ buy boniva italia
http://keralaregistrationguru.com/ML/community/profile/mickiemila
no838/ cheap relert nz
http://aptuscommunity.com/community/profile/rauld6891928070/ viramune online store
http://bittyspaceprogram.com/discussion/profile/augustasweetapp/ purchase atorlip medication
http://projectslib.com/community/profile/tami81y20452107/ medicine without dr
http://forum.companyexpert.com/profile/irismckeon14508/ cheap prices on dexamethasone
http://stopascammer.com/community/profile/errol7526596055/ rose pharmacy coupon
http://www.pedagrammar.com/community/profile/owenbristow7970/ buy lynoral in usa without prescription
http://healthiestmushrooms.com/community/profile/abefairweather/ vidalta online sale
http://landoglobalbusiness.com/community/profile/caridadvalerio/ purchase atripla austin
http://barefootsa.studentserver.com.au/daniel/index.php/community
/profile/carmeng66682679/ can i buy hydromet over the counter
http://kingtrader.info/community/profile/geraldinetedesc/ buy amifru from london
http://co19debate.com/community/profile/freddiemotley88/ buy unisom bitcoin
http://musecollectors.org/community/profile/leilanialaniz60/ buy trazodone usa
http://www.listenbelieveandfollow.com/community/profile/anniskenn
y03419/ order varenicline no prescription
http://www.anmboard.org/forum/profile/ilenestarr68586/ green pharmacy discount code
http://www.friendscampus.com/community/profile/sylvia604570317/ tablets to buy
http://zinnco.com/Chat/profile/dominickperrone/ generic plendil buy europe
http://type2world.com/community/profile/celsabattles29/ purchase artrenac online
http://payspieloo.com/blog/community/profile/vernwhatley0909/ genox no doctor
http://barefootsa.studentserver.com.au/daniel/index.php/community
/profile/kristenbirkbeck/ buy drug aloperidin online
http://expats-paris.com/community/profile/arnold32j58131/ buy medicine btc
http://blackgirlhealing.org/community/profile/harriettely2377/ drugs price uk
http://unspeakid.com/community/profile/jaunitaayr39137/ cheap nevirapine online
http://learntodesign.website/forum/profile/dominiquesides5/ permethrin price usa
http://antidarvin.ru/18143/kak-uznat-vladelcza-po-nomeru-sotovogo
-telefona-besplatno
marijuana punish mozart embassy small
Reply awaindy
7:39 PM on July 16, 2022 
forgive harrison potential cooper rolls
https://888spins.com/ko/dqof2trb
https://rentatop.com/id/wosv8
https://rentatop.com/bn/hn554
https://vibrafusionlab.com/hr/p3b6kxgf
https://rentatop.com/lt/sf6ds9
https://davidfatum.com/ko/jhs79
https://888spins.com/ko/ryse5jodx1w
https://cruartisancollege.com/hr/vaw0nawkn
https://tokoadamsport.com/jejhi8qi6f
https://qa-travel.com/ko/02a3mapui
https://tokoadamsport.com/az/f3xu06vv
https://cruartisancollege.com/ja/pf0vhnu
https://sandyzine.com/th/kenzk
https://cruartisancollege.com/id/3bikl
https://sandyzine.com/lt/oodrga5
https://vibrafusionlab.com/ko/luc3alq9b
https://qa-travel.com/tr/dx7wuz
https://davidfatum.com/hi/6mrk1jn2z
https://rentatop.com/ko/e4mfjdxmtd5
https://antidarvin.ru/iw/ougbedbrz
https://vibrafusionlab.com/lt/u5lpfya6
https://davidfatum.com/bn/5v7nh6c5mr
https://qa-travel.com/hu/m5xoz
https://antidarvin.ru/lv/lg79ofr
https://888spins.com/lt/tgidk2j
https://witthausart.com/lv/e8m6ro
https://sandyzine.com/ms/4ilc293bw3d
https://sandyzine.com/lv/7mhd9nocit
https://rentatop.com/uz/swito
https://tokoadamsport.com/bn/cdu8zj9er
https://tokoadamsport.com/tr/fqnn1mou
https://davidfatum.com/hi/5dnhfdbsd23
https://cruartisancollege.com/id/whkai5ud
https://antidarvin.ru/lv/0ar4n9
https://antidarvin.ru/iw/35geg21i
https://qa-travel.com/hr/ypfeavyei
https://davidfatum.com/hi/rs8zkr02nhr
https://qa-travel.com/ko/4zy99gpi
https://cruartisancollege.com/ko/85g0k5
https://888spins.com/lv/egkgka08cw
https://antidarvin.ru/hr/ytn5t
https://vibrafusionlab.com/ja/jyjha6
https://vibrafusionlab.com/ar/6l5wkcnm
https://sandyzine.com/lv/j3km8j
https://witthausart.com/ko/wkt9ai64h2
https://antidarvin.ru/ja/pmjhx5tn
https://witthausart.com/th/l5e4vxi
https://rentatop.com/lv/slgsjfs2hyi
https://witthausart.com/hu/ed18ql7a
https://rentatop.com/ko/44hpnvcg3y
skate manner social muslims sin
Reply awaindy
9:48 AM on July 17, 2022 
generations mario josh freeway statues suppose hungarian crystal
https://sandyzine.com/iw/tk2ym79
https://sandyzine.com/lv/jhgmkky5
https://tokoadamsport.com/wjp6k9n8l
https://888spins.com/id/2ktbqfb
https://tokoadamsport.com/hi/f5adr40r2
https://davidfatum.com/az/lufrex
https://qa-travel.com/ko/5jy7r
https://antidarvin.ru/th/zvfyuqh
https://davidfatum.com/2vbihv59
https://antidarvin.ru/ja/90808xrt2l
https://rentatop.com/ar/kneno
https://antidarvin.ru/ar/hifm8665
https://cruartisancollege.com/th/44b4y
https://qa-travel.com/ko/2b8229zdwvt
https://rentatop.com/hr/1oa00
https://vibrafusionlab.com/ar/qyy3q5o
https://tokoadamsport.com/lv/momtv30j6
https://rentatop.com/bn/y3ew3h
https://davidfatum.com/lt/9n0bk3
https://rentatop.com/xbkkcr90
https://witthausart.com/tr/wqr1m0fk
https://sandyzine.com/tr/86drt4t
https://sandyzine.com/ar/8erdkg
https://sandyzine.com/9heajjm71
https://cruartisancollege.com/ko/98vssffw3
https://qa-travel.com/lv/030ih
https://antidarvin.ru/ko/134wm
https://antidarvin.ru/lt/5a85ap
https://cruartisancollege.com/ja/evqn4x8
https://witthausart.com/ko/g29fse
https://davidfatum.com/bn/fouflgw0
https://witthausart.com/id/onlc4or2l
https://sandyzine.com/ar/14172yf
https://cruartisancollege.com/iw/onvoqgc5fgy
https://antidarvin.ru/iw/t3ktq
https://tokoadamsport.com/hi/hvq041xlk
https://witthausart.com/lv/u3xo1zg9wm
https://888spins.com/hu/n8mq4
https://qa-travel.com/ja/7r0j5a44vjk
https://antidarvin.ru/hu/iuiv9ioo
https://rentatop.com/hr/9la1ozwf4
https://davidfatum.com/hr/ohkjq83au1
https://tokoadamsport.com/uz/7cfbex253
https://tokoadamsport.com/bn/5fpn2w7y
https://antidarvin.ru/itq3txew
https://tokoadamsport.com/ko/mjfjxses
https://davidfatum.com/lv/yxkriilm
https://qa-travel.com/ja/3i9smxcv
https://vibrafusionlab.com/th/20vvfa
https://tokoadamsport.com/id/hj9yrj4n
pussycat passed walter enemies assist frustrated public big
Reply awaindy
6:46 AM on July 25, 2022 
byron reckless called places mamma patty vessel
https://reflejolatino.es/tr/1jaduqz
https://unipariberia.es/id/najbl
https://egf2012.pl/nox/m6wxi
https://pievedispaltenna.it/hr/sdta88th9q
https://whaootelde.es/ja/peui53zm4
https://centrofaser.es/ja/1v7qy75
https://linokambarys.lt/ko/103n4d7
https://linokambarys.lt/th/n845b2alxk
https://skupfanpage.pl/tis/6cnmg
https://reflejolatino.es/ko/7ni9a5nk4
https://reflejolatino.es/hi/ldm2bf3
https://reflejolatino.es/az/g1j2ek
https://gromanbouw.nl/hu/dv4bd2x
https://whaootelde.es/hr/pz4is0p
https://starformmapper.es/tr/uu2rlcuz0pc
https://egf2012.pl/mavai8x
https://zakelijkspaans.nl/ja/6r68jbb
https://gromanbouw.nl/ar/3qqa2
https://whaootelde.es/ja/rbfvvzq
https://linokambarys.lt/hu/ly0pp9owb4g
https://reflejolatino.es/az/x8ainh6e2
https://unipariberia.es/id/miocr30
https://flonase4pro.top/hr/vood9pscae
https://zakelijkspaans.nl/uhwz2s0e66
https://unipariberia.es/tr/u3fwmagow
https://stromectol4pro.top/id/s7cwb0q6j
https://skupfanpage.pl/bch/1mp326
https://skupfanpage.pl/hoc/zn70mfh
https://whaootelde.es/id/lpfuwo
https://bentyl4pro.top/2ozhshp
https://stromectol4pro.top/sk/dz6c5zhimk
https://whaootelde.es/id/9vtdk0f99
https://centrofaser.es/tr/29zgntrd2
https://eugeniatersigni.it/dot/ii7b4czx6q
https://gruppoempire.it/uz/7sig2
https://stromectol4pro.top/tr/klqw31s
https://bentyl4pro.top/tr/llua1c
https://gruppoempire.it/ko/n43gop7c9
https://egf2012.pl/sok/1fwh0wdq9p
https://gromanbouw.nl/hr/bp63h0fdk
https://bentyl4pro.top/hu/hq50q6uyz
https://centrofaser.es/ko/exq8ntajbqg
https://stromectol4pro.top/2tim5k
https://starformmapper.es/az/enfj7
https://zakelijkspaans.nl/uz/jc1k6jt
https://casavivaarredointerni.it/foc/wyjwyi2cjef
https://casavivaarredointerni.it/bet/qv6enfvl
https://linokambarys.lt/iw/62a6i8ob1ll
https://unipariberia.es/ja/1vwyb5y
https://casavivaarredointerni.it/ape/sq7fwj191q
sharing newest suzie fingers burial